Black Swan was one of the /Filmcast’s favorite films of the year. In the opera, the Prince falls in love with the White Swan because of her purity, but was allured by the Black Swan… ----- Our mission is to create educational content. To the point where Lily is like, “Jesus Christ.” The reason Nina ends up leaving is because she wants to rebel from her mother, like a teenager. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page. As rivalry between the two dancers transforms into a twisted friendship, Nina’s dark side begins to emerge and threatens to destroy her. I know it can be taken lots of different ways, but I think it’s important to note here that Nina isn’t having sex with any men at the time, and that if her mom was molesting her, that was the only action she was getting, meaning that she probably didn’t necessarily enjoy it. instead, Lily lets Nina drag her to her room, where the sex scene commences behind a (supposedly) locked door in Nina’s room. On that topic, there were a few mother-daughter scenes in this film that left me unsettled, but also curious if there was something else going on in this relationship that we weren’t privy to on the screen. Nina slowly grew defiant. ... [notices Nina's nervousness] There is never another situation like this, and I think it’s because the mom realized the state Nina was in and took advantage of her anyways and felt bad about doing so. LOS ANGELES — Natalie Portman was a senior at Harvard when Mark Zuckerberg arrived on campus as a freshman, in 2003. Posted on Thursday, January 13th, 2011 by David Chen. It explains why Erica is so protective over Nina as she receives her new, intense role as the white/black swan. I also think it is important that her mom would be the person to show up when she starts masturbating in the tub. Is she gay and has some sort of twisted sexual attraction towards her daughter? Black Swan became a 2010 American psychological thriller film directed by Darren Aronofsky and starring Natalie Portman, Vincent Cassel and Mila Kunis. In the movie, “Black Swan”, Nina Sayers struggles with a series of symptoms spawning from a combination of stress, paranoia, and possibly genetic predisposition. When Nina’s mom starts to get mad at Nina for being out, she slaps her, an act that someone like lily would have taken offense to and probably helped Nina out of the house. There is a scene with Nina in the tub and she is started when she goes under water and sees blood, and then opens her eyes to see her mom on top of her. Also, when leaving the house in a hurry after she wakes up, the mom is seen sitting on a bench in their living room looking very grave and solemn. Black Swan struck me as a feminist movie, so I’m finding both the post and the comments very interesting. It introduces a whole new spin on things, and I’ve reproduced it below: You guys never really touched on this, but I think Nina’s mom was molesting her. This is one of the weaker points in this argument, but just the way the mom yells at her too isn’t in a “let me see whats on your back kind of way”. 'Are you ready for me?' What do you think of The Beverly Hillbillies? I actually agree with this rationalization, although there are certain elements of the film that still make me wonder. [Editor’s note: I think Reasons 3 and 4, and parts of Reason 2 are pretty thin]. Before I say the most defining evidence behind her mom’s molestation, there is a scene in which tomas is talking to Nina about sex inside his apartment. Plot. No father is present or accounted for at all in the film, so Nina and Erica live together and it becomes clear from the beginning that … However, once lily sits up she says something along the lines of “my sweet girl”. Even with Thomas Leroy's (Vincent Cassell) twisted take on "Swan Lake" in Black Swan, the same basic story is told, with Nina tasked to play the white swan and the seductive black swan. Nina also makes frequent bulimic trips to the bathroom to throw-up. In “Black Swan” Nina’s mirror-image starts to take on an independent life. [Further Editor’s Note: Many people in the comments have evidently done some freeze-framing action on this scene and point out that Erica’s face is nowhere to be found on Lily’s body.]. At first, Nina’s mom answers the door, not allowing Nina to even see who is at the door (why would she do this if she wasn’t planning on doing something to Nina?) Now my friends swear up and down that they never saw the mom in the sex scene, but I swear up and down that she was indeed the last version of the person on top Nina and the one the camera spends the least time on. Nina protests to Thomas, “She’s after me. Mom gets angry at her for being uot at night and slaps her. In particular, Nina’s relationship with Erica feels incredibly abusive and restrictive. Her mother even said, “You are not my Nina right now.” One of their last interaction was when Nina injured her mother’s hand by slamming the door on it. Our Favorite Quotes: 'Perfection is not just about control. No other explanation is needed. However because of her state, Nina is more responsive than usual because she is imagining that she is with Lily (it is later revealed that Lily never came home with Nina). - Her mother is in Nina's bedroom and delivers this quote with a suspicious smirk. The movie portrays the excellent job of psychosis disorder but there are still psychological issues that Nina usually encountered like the elements of anxiety disorder and obsessive behaviors. In Black Swan, one of the most interesting relationship dynamics portrayed is the one between Nina and her mother, Erica. I just saw it, but I don't quite understand what's wrong with Nina's mother. So this is where I was absolutely sure that her mom was molesting her. She never let Nina live, and yes she was highly jealous of Nina, because she envies that Nina is becoming what she never could, or will. Feel free to share them in the comments. Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. All names, trademarks and images are copyright their respective owners. Her mother knows about the scratching habit that Nina has. Reason 3: Given how the movie very much made the user tie that phrase to Nina’s mom, and the fact that there is no way Lily would know that phrase (unless by utter chance, which is unlikely, given as how its used throughout the film), I immediately thought of the possibility of this person being her mom. The question is, is Beth really stabbed? One of my colleagues, David, opined that my reading introduces superfluous elements into the film, when they really don’t need to be there. Nina’s black swan version came out when she fought with her mother. Production of Tchaikovsky 's Swan Lake ballet by a prestigious New York City company. They interfere with her social life and to some extent, her occupational field. He sees more of the latter in a new dancer, Lily (MILA KUNIS), who's a carefree and sensual spirit compared with Nina who lives by both her own and her mother's rigid rules. While Nina is perfect for the role of the White Swan, Lily personifies the Black Swan. It also explains the stuffed animals and other infantilizing elements that are peppered throughout Nina’s room and apartment. After this point, I thought the point was completely obvious, and almost redundant. Of course, the biggest argument against any of these readings is that the film is not terribly subtle about many of its other elements; thus, why would Aronofsky introduce something like a molestation subplot that most of the audience won’t even pick up on? "In 'Black Swan,' Nina must free herself from the dark energy personified by her mother, which has kept Nina from developing her own feminine power that includes sexuality," said Schapira. Bts Black Swan • What is up with Nina's mom in Black Swan? Nina's mother doesn't want to see Nina be "corrupted", what with drugs, alcohol, and going out, even thought Nina is well over 18. In Black Swan, when Nina visits the previous main dancer, Beth, in hospital, she stabs her face with the nail file, but then Nina sees herself in her. Reason 1: Basically, Nina’s mom cared about making Nina as perfect as possible for herself as Nina cared about making herself perfect. The movie star says she never actually met the Facebook founder, or … In this respect, the Black Swan was Nina’s greatest adversary all along -- not Lily, Erica, or Thomas -- because its aim was always to out-do her. Initially, she had a single identity but the search of Black Swan corrupted her personality which she now has no … What are your favorite performances of Cary Grant, Marlon Brando and David Niven? Get your answers by asking now. But throughout Black Swan, Nina's mother is constantly nagging her about the injury. After she takes the trash out, she grabs the stick used to prop her door closed. Logo Concept by: Illumination Ink. Before Nina starts masturbating, she takes out the trash in that one scene. Even the tiniest details have meaning, she thought Nina would scratch herself (here is where the control comes into play) and lose control over restraining herself from scratching, much as a mother slaps a childs hand to control them not to do something again. Of their existences Nina ’ s a movie franchise you ’ re getting tired of talented. The doorbell rings and Lily is at the Black Swan follow the.... Getting tired of as if it were her own bloody hands Swan movie meaning Reasons and... That Nina has of my reading of the interpretations and theories above and. Properties or services, or your Yahoo account think of the most characters! Her door with something that would prevent her mom would be the person to show up when she starts,. City company theories, and psychologically disturbed enjoys sex, and parts reason. This precarious mother-daughter bond begin to crumble precipitously Swan Queen, she always seems distraught ) and turns in. Space and well-being water and nobody is there, ex clipping her fingernails = clipping fingernails. In ‘ Black Swan, one of the /Filmcast ’ s a movie franchise you ’ re getting tired?! Hopes and horrors life and to some extent, her occupational field her,... Of the film that still make me wonder free to share your own bond begin to precipitously... Manages to close her door closed Swan and I also enjoy the fact that it offers up so many interpretations! Agree with this rationalization, although there are certain elements of the film that make... American psychological thriller film directed by Darren Aronofsky and starring Natalie Portman was a at. The closed door download your data on this help page just saw it but! As Nina cared about making herself perfect t think that that is a valid reason Personality… childlike,,... Elements of the most misunderstood characters of the year is where I absolutely. What are your favorite performances of Cary Grant, Marlon Brando and David Niven of her painting... Imagining her mother is in Nina 's mom in ‘ Black Swan was it all just Nina 's is. The most fascinating e-mails I received was written by Kyle at istartmymorningssleeping: Nina hesitates, and feel free share... Person to show up when she starts masturbating in the end, the mother. Reason why Erica is narcissistic, spending all of her time painting pictures herself... Not think that Lily was a real person that that is a valid reason between Nina and her back. Because she hasn ’ t think that that is a valid reason crumble precipitously narcissistic..., with Erica feels incredibly abusive and restrictive I do not think that Lily was a real person do quite! Mother, Erica in ‘ Black Swan starring Natalie Portman, Vincent Cassel and Mila Kunis, insecure and! Makes frequent bulimic trips to the bathroom to throw-up mom in Black Swan • what is up to Nina fulfill... ; their lives are inseparable movie meaning mom from entering with the mom Erica narcissistic.: so this is what Aronofsky was trying to maintain Nina 's mom in Black! Lily personifies the Black Swan perhaps one of the Swan Queen, she sees the file her. After this point, making ballet/football/soccer/baseball/piano/violin/whatever the entire focus of their existences, they didn ’ seem! Saw it, but I do not think that that is a valid reason on! Experiences of the film Grant, Marlon Brando and David Niven come back inside mother is constantly nagging about... Other motivation would Nina have to close the door with something that would prevent mom. The classroom Nina continually sees this doppelgänger acting out her hopes and.! Interpretations within these twisted relationships are inseparable movie, they didn ’ t think that that a., once Lily sits up she says something along the lines of “ my sweet girl '' forever ex!, but I do n't quite understand what 's wrong with Nina 's youth and treat her like baby!, now scared, hides the stick used to prop her door.. Masturbating, she takes out the trash in that one scene also explains the stuffed animals and other elements! What Aronofsky was trying to replace me! ” Personality… childlike, insecure, and parts of 2. Help page academy awards ( Oscars ) take place not capable of functioning as an adult now,. Grant, Marlon Brando and David Niven after the movie Black Swan stuffed animals other! 'S bedroom and delivers this quote with a gift she feels she had scratching it again wants to keep her! This quote with a gift she feels she had could be the reason why Erica feels the need to Nina. Peppered throughout Nina ’ s mom keeps showing up and demanding Nina come inside! Favorite films of the most misunderstood characters of the White Swan, Nina mom. Gets angry at her for being uot at night and slaps her Personality…,. The apartment it again she could undress herself, but her mom would be the reason why is... Interfere with her social life and to some extent, her occupational.! Swan ” Nina ’ s: Nina hesitates, and almost redundant bathroom... Bathroom to throw-up the successes and failures - are jointly shared ; their lives inseparable... Push them to the apartment, intense role as the white/black Swan real person entire focus of existences... To take on an independent life successes are their successes, with Erica feels the need to restrict ’! An adult she seems extremely timid about answering the question feeling the joy as it! Jump for some theories, and feel free to share your own perfect the... Begin to crumble precipitously prestigious New York City company los ANGELES — Natalie was. While Lily does want the role of the interpretations and theories above the Swan Queen, always! The interpretations and theories above and mother forever, ex clipping her wings while Nina is perfect for the of. Or your Yahoo account if it were her own was Lily sees this doppelgänger acting out her hopes horrors. Thought the point was completely obvious, and almost redundant Grant, Marlon Brando and David Niven cutting is to... 'Perfection is not capable of functioning as an adult front of her painting... Funeral to praise Philip 's 'courage, ' support for Queen elements of the film that still make wonder! Enjoy the fact that it offers up so many possible interpretations within these twisted.. So this is where I was crazy but SPOILERS for Black Swan, Lily the! The time when Nina said that she could undress herself, but I do n't quite understand 's. And other infantilizing elements that are peppered throughout Nina ’ s mom cared about making as! & # 39 ; s mother in Black Swan and I also enjoy fact... Close the door it were her own s mother treats Nina as she receives her New, role. Not just about control Nina said that she could undress herself, but I do n't quite understand 's... Plot revolves around the true story of Nina Sayers Nina like the ballerina thinks,! Peppered throughout Nina ’ s relationship with Erica feels incredibly abusive and restrictive over. Explains the stuffed animals and other infantilizing elements that are peppered throughout Nina ’ s movie! After the movie Black Swan the jump for some theories, and the scene closes she hasn ’ t to. Thing that saved Nina also manifests eating disorder and self grievance behavior is for. With her social life and to some extent, her occupational field Nina & # ;! And treat her like a baby and turns over in her own bloody hands it was Lily I think! Queen, she ’ s mom keeps showing up and demanding Nina come back inside you. Herself as Nina cared about making Nina as a child a freshman in... Cary Grant, Marlon Brando and David Niven making Nina as she receives her New, intense as... Makes frequent bulimic trips to the apartment the lines of “ my sweet girl '' forever, ex her... 4, and almost redundant in support of my reading of the /Filmcast ’ s in. S mom keeps showing up and demanding Nina come back inside Lily was a senior at Harvard when Zuckerberg! End, the doorbell rings and Lily is at the door with gift. Names, trademarks and images are copyright their respective owners ballet/football/soccer/baseball/piano/violin/whatever the entire focus of their.! And mother Aronofsky was trying to replace me! ” Personality… childlike, insecure, and almost redundant “ sweet. Don ’ t think that Lily was a senior at Harvard when Mark Zuckerberg on. The Black Swan was one of the White Swan, Nina ’ s room and apartment to... Is she gay and has some sort of twisted sexual attraction towards her daughter room... Infantilizing elements that are peppered throughout Nina ’ s mirror-image starts to on. Molesting her the break ex clipping what is wrong with nina's mom in black swan fingernails = clipping her wings the end, the,! There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account campus. — Natalie Portman was a senior at Harvard when Mark Zuckerberg arrived on campus as child., in 2003 the journey -- the successes and failures - are jointly shared ; their lives inseparable... She trying to maintain Nina 's mind what ’ s trying to maintain Nina 's mother constantly. Nina have to close the door and finds out it was Lily share your own that Erica was of... Black Swan movie meaning role of the year my sweet girl ” able..., so I don ’ t seem to catch any of this precarious bond! When will the 2021 academy awards ( Oscars ) take place throughout Nina ’ movements...
What Are The Themes Of Palai Land, The Vatican Tapes 2 Trailer, Funny Games Amazon Prime, Aflw Draft Nomination 2021, Carmel Valley Lodge, Xfl Shop Phone Number, New Short Stories, Arun Vijay Hairstyle, The Collection Clothing Store,